Skip over navigation
Advanced Search

I was a fanatic...I know their thinking, says former radical Islamist

By HASSAN BUTT - More by this author » Last updated at 07:38am on 2nd July 2007

Comments Comments (21)

hassan butt
When I was still a member of what is probably best termed the British Jihadi Network - a series of British Muslim terrorist groups linked by a single ideology - I remember how we used to laugh in celebration whenever people on TV proclaimed that the sole cause for Islamic acts of terror like 9/11, the Madrid bombings and 7/7 was Western foreign policy.

By blaming the Government for our actions, those who pushed this "Blair's bombs" line did our propaganda work for us.

More important, they also helped to draw away any critical examination from the real engine of our violence: Islamic theology.

The attempts to cause mass destruction in London and Glasgow are so reminiscent of other recent British Islamic extremist plots that they are likely to have been carried out by my former peers.

And as with previous terror attacks, people are again saying that violence carried out by Muslims is all to do with foreign policy.

For example, on Saturday on Radio 4's Today programme, the Mayor of London, Ken Livingstone, said: "What all our intelligence shows about the opinions of disaffected young Muslims is the main driving force is not Afghanistan, it is mainly Iraq."

I left the British Jihadi Network in February 2006 because I realised that its members had simply become mindless killers. But if I were still fighting for their cause, I'd be laughing once again.

Mohammed Sidique Khan

Mohammed Sidique Khan met with the author on two separate occasions

Mohammad Sidique Khan, the leader of the July 7 bombings, and I were both part of the network - I met him on two occasions.

And though many British extremists are angered by the deaths of fellow Muslim across the world, what drove me and many others to plot acts of extreme terror within Britain and abroad was a sense that we were fighting for the creation of a revolutionary worldwide Islamic state that would dispense Islamic justice.

If we were interested in justice, you may ask, how did this continuing violence come to be the means of promoting such a (flawed) Utopian goal?

How do Islamic radicals justify such terror in the name of their religion?

There isn't enough room to outline everything here, but the foundation of extremist reasoning rests upon a model of the world in which you are either a believer or an infidel.

Formal Islamic theology, unlike Christian theology, does not allow for the separation of state and religion: they are considered to be one and the same.

For centuries, the reasoning of Islamic jurists has set down rules of interaction between Dar ul-Islam (the Land of Islam) and Dar ul-Kufr (the Land of Unbelief) to cover almost every matter of trade, peace and war.

But what radicals and extremists do is to take this two steps further. Their first step has been to argue that, since there is no pure Islamic state, the whole world must be Dar ul-Kufr (The Land of Unbelief).

Step two: since Islam must declare war on unbelief, they have declared war upon the whole world.

Along with many of my former peers, I was taught by Pakistani and British radical preachers that this reclassification of the globe as a Land of War (Dar ul-Harb) allows any Muslim to destroy the sanctity of the five rights that every human is granted under Islam: life, wealth, land, mind and belief.

In Dar ul-Harb, anything goes, including the treachery and cowardice of attacking civilians.

The notion of a global battlefield has been a source of friction for Muslims living in Britain.

For decades, radicals have been exploiting the tensions between Islamic theology and the modern secular state - typically by starting debate with the question: "Are you British or Muslim?"

But the main reason why radicals have managed to increase their following is because most Muslim institutions in Britain just don't want to talk about theology.

They refuse to broach the difficult and often complex truth that Islam can be interpreted as condoning violence against the unbeliever - and instead repeat the mantra that Islam is peace and hope that all of this debate will go away.

This has left the territory open for radicals to claim as their own. I should know because, as a former extremist recruiter, I repeatedly came across those who had tried to raise these issues with mosque authorities only to be banned from their grounds.

Every time this happened it felt like a moral and religious victory for us because it served as a recruiting sergeant for extremism.

Outside Britain, there are those who try to reverse this two-step revisionism.

A handful of scholars from the Middle East have tried to put radicalism back in the box by saying that the rules of war devised so long ago by Islamic jurists were always conceived with the existence of an Islamic state in mind, a state which would supposedly regulate jihad in a responsible Islamic fashion.

In other words, individual Muslims don't have the authority to go around declaring global war in the name of Islam.

But there is a more fundamental reasoning that has struck me as a far more potent argument because it involves recognising the reality of the world: Muslims don't actually live in the bipolar world of the Middle Ages any more.

The fact is that Muslims in Britain are citizens of this country. We are no longer migrants in a Land of Unbelief.

For my generation, we were born here, raised here, schooled here, we work here and we'll stay here.

But more than that, on a historically unprecedented scale, Muslims in Britain have been allowed to assert their religious identity through clothing, the construction of mosques, the building of cemeteries and equal rights in law.

However, it isn't enough for responsible Muslims to say that, because they feel at home in Britain, they can simply ignore those passages of the Koran which instruct on killing unbelievers.

Because so many in the Muslim community refuse to challenge centuries-old theological arguments, the tensions between Islamic theology and the modern world grow larger every day.

I believe that the issue of terrorism can be easily demystified if Muslims and non-Muslims start openly to discuss the ideas that fuel terrorism.

Crucially, the Muslim community in Britain must slap itself awake from its state of denial and realise there is no shame in admitting the extremism within our families, communities and worldwide co-religionists.

If our country is going to take on radicals and violent extremists, Muslim scholars must go back to the books and come forward with a refashioned set of rules and a revised understanding of the rights and responsibilities of Muslims whose homes and souls are firmly planted in what I'd like to term the Land of Co-existence.

And when this new theological territory is opened up, Western Muslims will be able to liberate themselves from defunct models of the world, rewrite the rules of interaction and perhaps we will discover that the concept of killing in the name of Islam is no more than an anachronism.

Comment Add your comment | View all Comments (21)

21 people have commented on this story so far. Tell us what you think below.

Here's a sample of the latest comments published. You can click view all to read all comments that readers have sent in.

What a brave statement. Hopefully this man is genuine in his conversion from extremist to a 'normal' muslim and can educate young muslims about living peacefully with 'non-believers'.

- Lou, Nottingham

Thank you so much for this article. So often there seem to be no views expressed by Muslims in the press, leading to complete ignorance of how Muslims may feel about terrorism, the West, and so on, with all the debate based on speculation by non-muslims. More articles and comment by more Muslims please.

- Sarah, Colchester

A most thoughtful and candid article, which will go a long way towards shedding light on the subject. Keep giving out your message, Hassan. If only the people who run this country would listen to you...

- Dave In Notts, UK

View all Add your comment


make text area biggerYou have  characters left.

Mail to a friend Print story Read later


©2007 Associated Newspapers Ltd · Terms & Conditions · Privacy
Femail kate middleton

It's a hard life Kate! After THAT concert, Wills' girl has a ball at Wimbledon
Kate Middleton has little reason to complain about her life. After watching the Diana concert from the Royal Box and dancing the night away at the after-party, the 25-year-old spent the next day recovering at Wimbledon with pals

Bedingfield

Racy Natasha makes moves on F1 ace Hamilton
Singer Natasha Bedingfield appeared to be making some fast moves on Lewis Hamilton at a party thrown by P Diddy. The pair emerged hand-in-hand from a people carrier

Liz and hubby

Has Liz Jones taken back her feckless, unfaithful husband?
The very public split between Liz Jones and her unfaithful husband Nirpal Dhaliwal takes a new twist. He says they're dating...

cherie

Is Cherie Blair misunderstood? Or bonkers?
'I'm not bonkers', insists Cherie Blair on TV this week. Here, with an affectionate reminder of some of her more diverting treatments, we invite you to make up your own mind

Margaret

Blue movies and casual flings - the amazing truth about Princess Margaret's marriage
Blue movies after dinner, passionate rows and casual flings ... read the truth about Princess Margaret's volatile marriage to Lord Snowdon


DON'T MISS...

Elton

Don't you know who I am? rages Elton in foul-mouthed rant at police

When Elton John's car was stopped by royal security, the veteran singer flew into one of his trademark rages
Kylie

Kylie joins the Doctor in the tardis for a Christmas special

Kylie Minogue will be getting her teeth into some out-of-this-world filming when she joins Dr Who
Lohan

Lindsay celebrates 21st with beach party... and Calum scores an invite

Bikini-clad Lindsay Lohan marked her 21st with a beach party, and squeeze Calum Best was invited
Jonathan

Day 35: Big Brother's Jonathan quits after grandmother's death

Jonathan Durden has left the Big Brother house after learning his grandmother has passed away
Lily Cole

Lily Cole leads top model charge at Dior's 60th anniversary

Lily Cole is among top models at an extravagant fashion show marking the 60th anniversary of Dior
paris

Paris is the main attraction as she's mobbed by tourists

Paris Hilton willingly pouts and poses for tourists lining up to have their picture taken with the ex-convict heiress
Eva

Eva Longoria's wild his 'n' hers bachelor party

Eva Longoria and fiance Tony Parker held 'his' and 'hers' bachelor parties ahead of their wedding

FANCY THAT...

Gorilla

Baby gorilla fights for life in hospital incubator

Doctors at a children's hospital are battling to save a baby gorilla abandoned by her mother at a zoo
stealth boat

Royal Marines' stealth boat - the latest weapon in war on terror

This new secret superboat is thought to be capable of reaching terrifying speeds of about 70mph
eu video

EU dirty video leaves red faces all round

The European Union has turned to shock tactics in its latest bid for self-promotion - making its own dirty video
news reader

Furious TV presenter sets fire to Paris Hilton story live on air

In a protest over having to read a story sbout Paris, anchorwoman screws up and tries to burn her script
yawning

Revealed: the secret of why we yawn

Scientists claim to have discovered the secret of why we yawn. They say it is the body's way of making us more attentive
pilgrimage

Kashmir's holy stalagmite vanishes ... again

Pilgrims were shocked to discover an ice stalagmite that forms in a Himalayan cave and is worshipped as a Hindu god has melted away
thelma bonnett

Live artillery shell used as a doorstep for 20 years

A pensioner was horrified to discover her doorstep - regularly polished and even used as a toy - was actually this live artillery shell

Warning: include(../../../google.php): Failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /web/westerfunk/archives/terrorism/I was a fanatic...I know their thinking, says former radical Islamist/index.php on line 1314

Warning: include(): Failed opening '../../../google.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:/usr/share/php') in /web/westerfunk/archives/terrorism/I was a fanatic...I know their thinking, says former radical Islamist/index.php on line 1314